Florida GOP Pulls James Fishback From Party Event as Governor’s Race Debate Fight Escalates

The Republican Party of Florida has rescinded gubernatorial candidate James Fishback’s invitation to participate in the party’s Sunshine State Showdown, turning a disagreement over debate rules into a larger public fight inside the GOP primary for Florida governor.

The party announced Friday that Fishback would no longer be included in the June 27 event in Hollywood or other official Republican gubernatorial primary activities. In its statement, RPOF said Fishback had first sought inclusion in the party’s official process, then announced plans to participate in a separate debate not sanctioned by the party.¹

Fishback had said at a Tallahassee press conference that a July 15 debate would move forward “whether Byron Donalds shows or not,” according to RPOF’s statement. The party said that violated its rules for candidates participating in official primary events.¹

RPOF Chairman Evan Power also accused Fishback of continuing what he described as “antisemitic and racist attacks” on members of the party. Those allegations should be understood as the party’s position, not as an independent finding by Tidings Media. Fishback and his supporters have framed the conflict differently, arguing that the party is trying to limit debate and protect the frontrunner.

The dispute comes as Republican candidates seeking to replace term-limited Gov. Ron DeSantis have been pressing for a public debate. The party’s criteria required candidates to show at least 10% support in polling, raise more than $10 million, and have more than 10,000 donors. According to WPTV/WFTS reporting, only U.S. Rep. Byron Donalds met all three thresholds.²

RPOF’s own polling, conducted June 9 and 10, showed Donalds leading the Republican field with 38.8% support. Lt. Gov. Jay Collins had 7.6%, Fishback had 4.1%, and former House Speaker Paul Renner had 2.2%. Nearly 43% of likely Republican primary voters were undecided.²

DeSantis criticized the debate requirements Friday, saying he likely would not have qualified under similar standards when he first ran for governor in 2018. He argued that debates should be arranged by candidates and media organizations rather than controlled by party officials.²

Donalds’ campaign has pushed back against demands for a debate. His communications director, Gates McGavick, said earlier in the week that it is not Donalds’ responsibility to “legitimize campaigns that have failed to gain meaningful support.”²

The result is a Republican primary fight with two overlapping issues: whether the party’s debate thresholds are too restrictive, and whether RPOF was justified in removing Fishback from its event after his announcement of a competing debate.

For voters, the practical effect is that the Sunshine State Showdown may not provide the full side-by-side comparison some candidates and voters have requested. The larger political question is whether the party’s attempt to impose order on the primary will calm the race or deepen the perception that the process is being managed from the top.

Tidings Media will continue tracking Florida’s 2026 governor’s race, including candidate debates, party rules, fundraising, polling, and ballot access.

For updates, subscribe to our free newsletter!

Footnotes

1. Republican Party of Florida, “Republican Party of Florida Rescinds James Fishback’s Invitation to Sunshine State Showdown,” June 12, 2026.
2. WPTV/WFTS, “DeSantis joins calls for Florida GOP governor debate as party bars Fishback from June event,” June 12, 2026.