Amendment 3 Was Florida's Tax Revolt. Now Local Officials Want Voters to Pay for It.

Image

On November 3, about 62 percent of Florida voters approved Amendment 3, clearing the 60 percent supermajority the constitution requires. The non-school homestead exemption rises to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028.¹ Voters did this after a year of warnings from mayors, sheriffs, county commissioners, police unions and chambers of commerce that libraries would close and parks would go dark. They heard all of it and voted yes anyway.



In 1773, colonists dumped tea in Boston Harbor because officials across an ocean were spending their money without asking. Florida's version happened at the ballot box, and the officials in question work at the county building down the road. From Pensacola to Miami, homeowners watched their tax bills climb every year while local budgets ballooned, and when they finally got a direct vote, they cut the money off at the source.

Amendment 3 is now part of the Florida Constitution. Repealing it would take another amendment and another 60 percent statewide vote.² The Tampa Bay Times has already floated an amendment to "fix" it, but that would need the same supermajority voters just used in the opposite direction. Any official waiting for a reversal is wasting a year that taxpayers are paying for.

Retaliation, county by county

Many local governments have answered the vote by going after the services families notice first. St. Johns County put a planned fire station on hold, and its commission chair described eliminating parks, libraries and health and human services to save about $50 million, a scenario he called hypothetical.³ Clearwater drew up a plan to cut nearly 140 full-time jobs and end funding for the Clearwater Historical Society and Keep Pinellas Beautiful.⁵ Largo calculated that closing its library and every park and recreation center would save just over $10 million.⁴ Library advocates say Volusia is looking at losing summer meals along with summer reading.⁶

In August, Pinellas County Commissioner Chris Latvala told beach community leaders the county would shut down libraries and close parks before touching public safety, and if it came to that, "so be it."¹⁰ Pinellas staff had already proposed eliminating the Fort De Soto lifeguards and cutting county funding for the Weedon Island and Shell Key preserves.¹¹ Tampa Mayor Jane Castor said the city would have to consider cutting services or charging residents fees to use them.⁴ None of these lists led with consultants, vehicle allowances, travel or administrative headcount. Officials picked the lifeguard stand because they knew it would make residents angry, and that is what a retaliation list is for.

Other governments went straight for the tax rate. Orlando's budget staff said the city may have to raise its millage rate for the first time in 13 years.⁷ A Sarasota County commissioner said the county may need to take a hard look at a higher rate.⁸ Voters cut the tax, and these governments are already talking about raising it back.

How officials talk about voters

Listen to the people who lost. Miami-Dade Mayor Daniella Levine Cava called the amendment deceptive, and Miami Commissioner Damian Pardo compared it to a payday loan.¹² Jacksonville Mayor Donna Deegan said it punishes places like hers.¹³ Their message to 62 percent of the state is that voters were fooled.

Pinellas has its own version. This month, after Pinellas County Commissioners Vince Nowicki and Chris Scherer called for Pinellas County Administrator Barry Burton to step aside, fellow Pinellas Commissioner René Flowers argued that Amendment 3 reflected voters' desire for property tax relief, not necessarily dissatisfaction with county leadership.¹⁴ That reading is convenient for anyone who voted for the budgets, because it treats the revolt as a complaint about the size of the bill and leaves the spending off the table.

Voters wanted lower bills and a leaner government, and they saw those as one demand. Nowicki said so from the Pinellas dais, calling the vote a sign of a fundamental disconnect between what voters want and the county's taxing and spending, and arguing that overhead should have been examined before libraries, healthcare and preserves.¹⁴ A few officials elsewhere heard it too. Jacksonville Councilman Rory Diamond said he would push for a 25 percent pay cut for city employees earning more than $100,000, adding, "Enough with the stupid programs."⁹ Incoming St. Petersburg Mayor Charlie Crist, who voted no, said savings come before any new fee.¹⁵ Hold every local official in Florida to that standard.

The money is there

Florida DOGE found that Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, Hillsborough and Orange counties budgeted $10.8 billion in general fund spending in fiscal 2025, up 49 percent from fiscal 2020-21.¹⁷ Miami-Dade's general fund grew about 80 percent over eight years.¹⁸ When state staff asked Miami-Dade to show where certain contracts were authorized in its budget, the county said that would take a "Herculean effort," according to the report.¹⁹ Population didn't grow anywhere near that fast. Home values did, and local governments spent the windfall.

Pinellas shows how modest the real cut is. Its fiscal 2027 budget is $5.137 billion across all funds,²⁰ up about 19 percent from $4.3 billion two years earlier.²¹ The county projects Amendment 3 will reduce general fund property tax revenue by about $124 million in fiscal 2028 and $184 million in fiscal 2029.²² The bigger number is about 3.6 percent of the total budget, so a 4 percent trim covers it.

In 2023 the same commission approved about $25 million in tourist-tax money for a Salvador Dalí Museum expansion priced at $65 million.²³,²⁴ Bed-tax money is restricted by state law, and officials will point that out. Their own Tourist Development Council has also discussed giving fast-growing tourism revenue a larger role in closing budget gaps.²⁵ They found a way to fund a museum wing, so they can find one for the lifeguards.

What the auditors found

Florida DOGE reviewed 13 local governments and alleged more than $1.86 billion in excessive spending, though it found no fraud.¹⁶ Jacksonville paid $75,000 for a hologram of its mayor greeting airport travelers and $7.5 million for a one-mile sidewalk. Broward spent $175,000 on virtual art in the Metaverse and $44,000 promoting a UN gender equity treaty. Orlando spent $460,000 on a tree inventory, Pensacola $300,000 on an equity-focused strategic plan, and Hillsborough $950,000 on employee vehicle allowances.²⁶

The report also cited a $9 million art allowance for a Miami-Dade detention center and a $125 million shore power program for cruise ships.²⁷ It accused Palm Beach County of $344 million in excess spending,²⁸ including an $88 million increase for paratransit.²⁹ Personnel costs in Florida's 10 largest cities rose more than $1 billion in four years.³⁰ Local officials dispute many of these figures. If they think the auditors got it wrong, they should publish their own line-by-line cuts, and so far most of them have published threats instead.

Ten ways to fight back

Fiscal 2028 begins October 1, 2027, for counties and most cities, and it is the first budget built under Amendment 3. That gives residents about ten months to organize. Every step below works in any Florida county or city.

  1. Get on the calendar now. Under Florida's truth-in-millage law, local governments mail TRIM notices in August and hold two public budget hearings in September, and by then most decisions are made. Look up your county's and city's spring and summer 2027 budget workshop dates today. Sign up for public comment at every one and bring your neighbors.
  2. Name them and shame them. Every time an official proposes closing a library, a preserve or a lifeguard stand while consultants and vehicle allowances survive, record who said it, the meeting date, the video timestamp and the exact words. Post it on social media and send it to local reporters. Stick to votes, motions, budget memos and on-camera quotes, because a documented record is hard to wave away.
  3. Demand the overhead list in writing. A new state law, HB 1329, requires cities and counties to publish lists of potential budget cuts starting next year.³¹ Email each commissioner and council member and ask them to put these at the top: outside consultants, travel and conferences, vehicle allowances and take-home cars, vacant positions, administrative jobs added since 2019, and nonessential capital projects. Ask for a written answer explaining why any of it should survive while a library closes.
  4. File public records requests. Chapter 119 of Florida law lets anyone request government records without giving a reason. Ask for consultant and lobbying contracts, vehicle allowance and take-home car policies, terminal leave payouts, three years of travel spending and every position added since 2021. Share what you get with neighbors and reporters.
  5. Follow the restricted money. Big budgets hold dedicated funds such as tourist taxes. Ask whether beach and park costs that visitors drive can be moved to the tourist-tax side, and ask your legislators to widen the allowed uses where state law is too narrow.
  6. Pressure Tallahassee. The Legislature still has to write the rules that carry out Amendment 3, and a special session has been floated.⁶ Call your state representative and senator with two requests: require local governments to document administrative cuts before they cut direct services, and bar them from recovering the tax cut through new fees.
  7. Shut the fee and rate backdoor. Tampa's mayor has talked about charging fees to use services,⁴ St. Petersburg has weighed a fire-service assessment,³² and Orlando and Sarasota County have floated higher millage rates.⁷,⁸ Each one claws back part of the vote. Oppose it at the hearing where it is proposed, and add its sponsors to your list from step two.
  8. Ask about their own pay. Before the vote, Axios asked Tampa Bay officials whether they would take a pay cut if Amendment 3 passed, and Pinellas Commissioner Chris Latvala said he would cut his salary.³³ Ask every commissioner and council member in your area the same question at a public meeting, on the record.
  9. Defend the targets directly. Join the friends groups for your libraries, parks and preserves, give money and volunteer. Officials have a harder time using a park as a bargaining chip when crowds keep showing up to defend it.
  10. Vote them out. County commission and city council seats come up on a regular cycle. Take the list from step two to the next election, and recruit candidates who will cut overhead first.

What they'll say, and how to answer

Officials will say most of the budget is restricted and public safety takes most of the rest. A 2025 Florida League of Cities analysis found that in 176 of Florida's 276 cities, police, fire and EMS spending already exceeds all property tax revenue.³⁴ In Pinellas the sheriff takes more than $501 million of the $1.125 billion general fund, so measured against that fund a $184 million loss is closer to 16 percent than 4.²⁰ The amendment lists public safety as a permitted use of property tax money but guarantees no funding level, and many officials read it as police and fire first.³⁶

Those are real constraints, and they make the case for cutting overhead first even stronger. With a smaller general fund, every dollar spent on consultants comes straight out of the library officials are threatening to close. They will also attack the state audit. Jacksonville's council auditor could verify only about $90 million of the $199 million DOGE attributed to the city,³⁵ and the report counted $30 million in police and fire pensions as wasteful because the fund manager had a DEI policy on its website.²⁸ If the state's audit is sloppy, local officials are free to publish a better one.

Then ask them why the first cuts offered across Florida are always the ones that hurt families, and why governments that grew their general funds by nearly half since 2021 can't find 4 percent without padlocking the places people go on Saturday. Sixty-two percent of voters already answered that question. Officials who respond by punishing those voters should hear about it at every meeting until the next election.



Notes

  1. NBC Miami, "Voters approve property tax cut, reject other ballot measures," Nov. 2026.
  2. WGCU, "Amendment 3 promises property tax relief — what would it cost the Suncoast?" Sept. 23, 2026.
  3. Jacksonville Today, "Amendment 3 fallout: St. Johns County puts fire station on hold, plans staff cuts," Nov. 11, 2026.
  4. FOX 13, "Tampa Bay Chamber, mayor oppose Amendment 3."
  5. Bay News 9, "Clearwater prepares for $20 million loss if Amendment 3 passes," Aug. 28, 2026.
  6. WCTV via MySuncoast, "Librarians urge Florida lawmakers to protect library services after the passage of Amendment 3," Nov. 10, 2026.
  7. Spectrum News 13, "Orlando weighs Amendment 3's potential impact during budget discussions," Sept. 15, 2026.
  8. Suncoast Searchlight, "Sarasota County proposes very small reduction to property tax rate," July 10, 2026.
  9. Action News Jax, "Amendment 3 passes in Florida; Jacksonville could face up to $200M budget deficit."
  10. Tampa Bay Beacons, "Latvala warns beach leaders: County bracing for deep cuts," Sept. 2, 2026.
  11. WUSF / St. Pete Catalyst, "Pinellas County is proposing major cuts to its Parks and Rec budget," Aug. 9, 2026.
  12. Local 10, "'Deceptive' Amendment 3 could force tough choices on key services, local leaders warn," Sept. 2, 2026.
  13. Jacksonville Today, "Jacksonville Civic Council comes out against Amendment 3 tax cut."
  14. Florida Politics, "Vince Nowicki, Chris Scherer call for Pinellas Administrator Barry Burton's departure," Nov. 12, 2026.
  15. Axios Tampa Bay, "Tampa Bay leaders plan for Amendment 3 impacts," Nov. 6, 2026.
  16. The Capitolist, "DeSantis' DOGE slams excessive spending, finds no fraud."
  17. Florida DOGE, "Report on Local Government Spending," Jan. 2026 (via Jacksonville Today).
  18. Miami Herald via AOL, "The DeSantis DOGE spotlight comes to Broward and Miami-Dade."
  19. Gulf Today, "New Florida DOGE report could be helpful," Feb. 8, 2026.
  20. St. Pete Catalyst, "County commissioners discuss fiscal year 2027 budget"; Pinellas County FY27 Proposed Budget.
  21. St. Pete Catalyst, "County commission approves $4.3 billion budget, tax cuts."
  22. St. Pete Catalyst, "What could property tax amendment mean for homeowners."
  23. St. Pete Rising, "Pinellas County Commission approves $25.2 million in funding for Dali Museum expansion plans," Aug. 1, 2023.
  24. The Dalí Museum, Expansion FAQ (expansion.thedali.org).
  25. WUSF, "Could booming tourism help ease Pinellas County's budget squeeze?" Aug. 26, 2026.
  26. Office of Gov. Ron DeSantis, press release, Oct. 1, 2025 (flgov.com).
  27. The Daily Signal, "Florida's DOGE Has Promoted Government Efficiency Under DeSantis," July 13, 2026.
  28. Florida Trib, "Florida DOGE wants to slash millions of dollars in alleged waste across local governments. A new report detailed far less," Jan. 31, 2026.
  29. Palm Beach Post via ArcaMax, Palm Beach County DOGE report coverage.
  30. Treasure Coast Newspapers via AOL, "Florida DOGE finds payroll for large cities 'surged' by $1 billion."
  31. Winter Park Voice, "On the Chopping Block: Police, Fire, Community Groups, Trash Collection."
  32. CPA Practice Advisor, "5 Questions After Florida Voters Approved Property Tax Ballot Amendment," Nov. 6, 2026.
  33. Axios Tampa Bay, "We asked Tampa Bay officials if they'd cut their pay if Amendment 3 passes," Oct. 21, 2026.
  34. PolitiFact via WLRN, "FL's Amendment 3 would cut property taxes. Could it gut local police, fire, emergency money?" Oct. 14, 2026.
  35. Jacksonville Today, "Florida DOGE report raises more questions than answers for City Council," Feb. 2026.
  36. Police1, "Fla. sheriffs weigh staffing, service cuts after Amendment 3 passes."


I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified
Spam
Offensive